Skip to content 
Choosing a medical school is one of the most significant decisions for anyone pursuing a career in medicine. One of the biggest questions students face today is whether to attend a Pass Fail medical schools or one that uses traditional grading. With both options becoming more popular, understanding the pros and cons of each is difficult to making the right decision.
In this post, we will dive into everything you need to know about Pass/Fail medical schools, what they offer, and how they compare to traditional grading systems.
What Is a Pass/Fail Medical School?
Simply put, a Pass/Fail medical school evaluates students with just two outcomes: pass or fail, instead of traditional letter grades like A, B, C, or F. This system is designed to ease the pressure of academic performance, focusing more on understanding concepts than competing for grades.
The Pros of Pass/Fail Medical Schools
Here are some pros of pass fail med school.
1. Reduced Stress
One of the primary advantages of a Pass/Fail system is the reduction in stress for students. Medical school can be highly stressful, and having to worry about grades on top of everything else only adds to that pressure. With the Pass/Fail system, as long as students pass their classes, they’re not judged on percentages, and this can allow them to focus more on learning rather than just chasing high scores.
2. Better Mental Health
With less emphasis on grades, many students experience better mental health in Pass Fail medical schools. The constant race to maintain top grades can cause burnout, anxiety, and even depression. But when you are not stressing over whether you will get an A or a B, you can focus on staying healthy and balanced.
3. Collaboration Over Competition
In traditional grading systems, there’s often a lot of competition among students for the best grades. However, in Pass/Fail schools, this competition is greatly minimized. Since everyone is focused on passing rather than outscoring each other, collaboration becomes a core aspect of learning. Students are more likely to help each other, forming a more supportive environment.
4. Focus on Learning, Not Memorizing
Many students find that the Pass/Fail system allows them to focus on actually understanding the material rather than memorizing facts just to get high scores. Medical school is about building a foundation for your future practice, and this system encourages deeper learning that sticks with you long-term.
5. Balanced Life
Medical school is tough, but it’s not the only thing happening in your life. If you have other priorities, like family or personal interests, a Pass/Fail school might offer more flexibility to maintain a work-life balance. Without the pressure of getting perfect grades, students can balance school with other life responsibilities.
The Cons of Pass/Fail Medical Schools
Like pros, there are also cons of pass/fail med school.
1. Lack of Class Ranking
One potential downside of the Pass/Fail system is the lack of a clear class ranking. For students aiming for highly competitive specialties like neurosurgery, dermatology, or orthopedic surgery, class rank can matter. If you’re at a Pass/Fail school, residency programs won’t see specific grades, which might make it harder to stand out among other applicants.
However, many Pass/Fail schools still rank students using quartiles (top 25%, top 50%, etc.), which residency programs can still consider. While this doesn’t give the exact grades, it provides a general sense of where you stand in your class.
2. Difficulty Standing Out
With grades being pass or fail, it can be harder for students to stand out when applying for competitive residency programs. When your transcript only shows pass or fail how can residency directors tell if you are a top student or just scraping by?
That said, students can stand out in other ways, such as:
- Getting strong letters of recommendation during clinical rotations.
- Excelling in Step 2 exams, which still use traditional scoring.
- Engaging in extracurricular activities, research, or leadership roles.
3. Competitiveness Isn’t Completely Gone
Although Pass/Fail schools tend to reduce competition, it doesn’t disappear entirely. Some students still feel the need to compete for residency placements and focus on getting into the top quartiles. So while the pressure of grades might be lower, the underlying competition for high ranks and impressive resumes remains.
How to Stand Out in a Pass/Fail Medical School
If you choose to attend a Pass/Fail medical school, there are still many ways to make yourself a strong candidate for residency programs. Here are a few tips:
1. Excel in Clinical Rotations
The third and fourth years of medical school offer hands-on learning through clinical rotations. Doing well during these rotations can help you earn stellar letters of recommendation from your preceptors, which can be highly influential when applying for residencies.
2. Perform Well on Step 2 Exams
While USMLE Step 1 exams are now Pass/Fail, Step 2 CK (Clinical Knowledge) exams still have scores. Residency programs will place a significant amount of weight on this exam, so doing well on Step 2 can help boost your application.
3. Engage in Extracurricular Activities
In competitive residency fields, having a well-rounded application is key. Extracurricular activities, such as volunteering, research, or medical-related clubs, can set you apart. Even hobbies unrelated to medicine can make you more appealing to program directors who value a balanced life.
How to Choose Between Pass/Fail and Traditional Grading Medical Schools
So, if you are lucky enough to have the option to choose between a Pass/Fail medical school and one with traditional grading, how should you decide?
1. Consider Your Goals
If you’re aiming for a highly specialized and competitive residency, such as in neurosurgery or dermatology, traditional grading may help you stand out. However, if you are more interested in primary care or less competitive specialties, a Pass/Fail system might be a better fit.
2. Evaluate Your Stress Levels
Medical school is intense no matter where you go, but some students thrive under pressure, while others feel crushed by it. If you know that grades add unnecessary stress to your life, a Pass/Fail system could be a better choice for your mental health and well-being.
3. Location and Environment
No matter the grading system, choosing a medical school is also about where you’ll be spending the next four years of your life. Pick a school where you’ll be happy living, with access to the resources and support you need to succeed.
4. Talk to Current Students
Reach out to current or former students at the schools you’re considering. They can give you valuable insight into the learning environment, how the grading system impacts daily life, and whether they feel supported.
The Future of Pass/Fail Medical Schools
As medical education continues to evolve, more schools are moving toward a Pass/Fail system. This shift reflects a growing emphasis on student well-being and reducing unnecessary stress. While this system may not be perfect, many believe it better aligns with the goal of medical education—to prepare compassionate, skilled physicians ready for residency and practice.
Real-Life Student Experiences
Here is a Sisi Zheng’s statement about Pass Fail Medical Schools System;
“Sisi Zheng said I am deeply impressed by the strong connections among Yale’s students, which reflected the kind of relationships I aimed to build in medical school. She also appreciated how the Yale Pass Fail System promotes a collaborative, non-competitive learning environment, giving students the freedom to pursue their education without the pressure of constant academic rivalry.”
Pass Fail Medical Schools List
Are you pre-med student looking for Which medical schools are pass/fail, so here is the complete Pass Fail Medical Schools List of the US.
| 1. Boston University School of Medicine |
| 2. Dartmouth College (Geisel School of Medicine) |
| 3. Drexel University College of Medicine |
| 4. George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences |
| 5. Harvard Medical School |
| 6. Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine |
| 7. Michigan State University College of Human Medicine (no internal ranking) |
| 8. Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine & Science |
| 9. Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School |
| 10. Tufts University School of Medicine |
| 11. Tulane University School of Medicine |
| 12. University of California, LA (David Geffen School of Medicine) |
| 13. University of California, San Diego School of Medicine |
| 14. University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine |
| 15. University of Southern California (Keck School of Medicine) |
| 16. University of Virginia School of Medicine |
| 17. Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine |
| 18. Wayne State University School of Medicine |
| 19. Western Michigan University Homer Stryker M.D. School of Medicine |
| 20. Yale School of Medicine |
Pass Fail Medical Schools FAQs
Is Harvad Medical School pass/fail?
Yes, Harvard Medical School preclinical years are pass fail, which allow the students to focus on learning and collaborative environment instead of ranking.
Is pass/fail bad for medical school?
Like every system, pass fail system has also some pros and cons. It can reduce stress, increase mental health and promote a learning environment. On the other hand, you need a good grade to stand out top in the residency matching cycle. But it can be overcome by extracurricular, publications and training.
List of pass fail medical schools in California?
There are total six pass or fail medical schools in California,
- Stanford University School of Medicine
- University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) School of Medicine
- University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) David Geffen School of Medicine
- University of California, San Diego (UCSD) School of Medicine
Is it easier to pass medical school in a pass/fail system?
It is true that pass fail system decreases the pressure on medical students but still its really hard to pass med school exam if you are not studying. Pass fail system also need regular studies.
Final Thoughts
Deciding whether to attend a Pass Fail medical school comes down to personal preference, career goals, and how you manage stress. If you are seeking a supportive, collaborative environment with less pressure on grades, a Pass/Fail medical school might be the right fit.
However, if you are aiming for a competitive specialty and want to ensure you have every advantage, a traditional grading system could offer more opportunities to stand out.
In the end, the key is to choose a medical school that aligns with your personal needs, professional goals, and life circumstances.
